University A100 applicants
36%
36 admitted out of 100
Less competitive9 / 10 admitted
More competitive27 / 90 admitted
Two fictional universities. Two types of program.
A has a higher admission rate in both.
| Admission rate | A University A | B University B |
|---|---|---|
| Less competitive program | 90% | 80% |
| More competitive program | 30% | 20% |
Which university has the higher overall admission rate?
The rates alone cannot tell us the overall winner. We also need the number of applicants in each group.
36 admitted out of 100
74 admitted out of 100
A wins in both programs. B wins overall.
Most A applicants chose the more competitive program.
Move the sliders. The admission rates within each program stay the same.
90% × 10% + 30% × 90% = 36%
80% × 90% + 20% × 10% = 74%
Before you trust an average,
ask who is in it.
This reversal is called Simpson's paradox.